NOM BLOG

Ed Whelan on Hawaii Judge Finding No Right to Same-Sex Marriage

 

Legal expert Ed Whelan comments on the good news for marriage out of Hawaii:

Via William Duncan at the Corner, I’ve learned of this strong and sound ruling yesterday in Hawaii by senior federal district judge Alan C. Kay holding that there is no federal constitutional right to same-sex marriage. Judge Kay determines (slip op. at 35-43) that the claim for such a right is foreclosed by the Supreme Court’s 1972 decision in Baker v. Nelson. Alternatively, properly applying rational-basis review and judicial restraint, he finds that such claim fails on the merits.

Because the proper exercise of rational-basis review has been so rare of late in the marriage context, I’m going to briefly outline Judge Kay’s reasoning... [continue reading]

One Comment

  1. Posted August 15, 2012 at 11:26 am | Permalink

    ".... there is no federal constitutional right to same-sex marriage. Judge Kay determines (slip op. at 35-43) that the claim for such a right is foreclosed by the Supreme Court’s 1972 decision in Baker v. Nelson."

    >> As has been admitted even by the First Circuit.

    "Alternatively, properly applying rational-basis review and judicial restraint, he finds that such claim fails on the merits."

    >> Given the Chief Justice's reference to electoral outcomes in the Obamacare decision, I would say the pseudo-marriage movement has a very large problem on their hands.

    SCOTUS might even decide to address the shocking perversion of Justice perpetrated by their old pal Vaughn Walker first ........