Melanie McDonagh's Spirited Defense of Marriage


Melanie McDonagh, a journalist who lives in London, offers a provocative and creative defense of marriage in the UK Spectator:

...In other words, objection to gay marriage isn’t about religion at all and the letter that the bishops are sending to Catholic churches does, to do them credit, make that clear.

It’s all to do with the nature of marriage. And that is, a natural institution providing the optimal situation for raising children. It’s vulgarly biological, marriage — a state for bringing up children in. And that’s how it’s been for almost all of human history. Even in ancient Greece, which practically invented homosexuality — alright, it was especially about the Socratic master-pupil relationship — reserved marriage for men and women, for the conceiving and bearing of children. And it’s that fundamental character of marriage which makes it essentially heterosexual. It’s to do with the complementarity of the sexes. Men and women fulfill different roles when it comes to the rearing of their offspring, and even in an atypical family like my own, in which I’m the sole breadwinner, those complementary roles make sense. Children relate differently to mothers and fathers; they pick up cues about how the sexes work, even children who go on to become gay. And departing from that biological foundation for marriage is a radically new departure.


  1. Posted March 10, 2012 at 8:30 pm | Permalink

    Stand strong for marriage in the UK. Kudos Melanie.

  2. ResistSSA
    Posted March 11, 2012 at 12:39 pm | Permalink

    I saw a show the other night about the ancient Spartans: shipped the boys off at the age of 7 to bond and have sexual contacts with the elder soldiers. Homosexuality a learned behavior.

    THEN, when it's time to reproduce,what do they do? The get ....wait for it...MARRIED! So, even in the most accepting of homosexual societies, marriage is reserved for one male, one female. Duh.

  3. Brian
    Posted March 15, 2012 at 10:01 am | Permalink

    So, by this reasoning, the infertile and heterosexual couples who are past reproductive age shouldn't be allowed to marry legally. They're essentially opposite-gender faggots.

Comments are temporarily disabled. Please try back later.